alternative to e collar dog

{"cid":"91194508","title":"Durable Soft Nylon Buckle Dog Collars , Purple Green Nylon Dog Collar Easy On Off","imgUrl":"https:\/\/img.chinax.com\/nimg\/b0\/1f\/201e45bad1bc6795985b3c3b0314-200x200-1.jpg","attrs":{"Price":"Negotiable","Brand Name":"Customized","Model Number":"KACOL012","Minimum Order Quantity":"Negotiable","Delivery Time":"10 working days","Place of Origin":"China","Payment Terms":"L\/C, T\/T, Western Union, MoneyGram","Supply Ability":"3000pcs\/week","Packaging Details":"Carton Box","Product Name":"Soft Nylon Dog Collar with Quick Snap Buckle","Size":"Multiple,Customized","Material":"Nylon","Color":"Blue,Red,Pink,Black,Green,etc","Application":"For Dog running,walking,hunting,etc","OEM\/ODM":"Available"}}

{"cid":"91212044","title":"Double Triple Pets Choke Chain Dog Training Metal Choke Chain Collar With Welded Ring","imgUrl":"https:\/\/img.chinax.com\/nimg\/b8\/a0\/c0e1de520b094b19e5a94ad96424-200x200-1.jpg","attrs":{"Price":"negotiate","Brand Name":"Durastark","Model Number":"DP-C007","Minimum Order Quantity":"3000pcs","Delivery Time":"20-30 days","Certification":"ISO9001","Place of Origin":"China","Payment Terms":"T\/T, Western Union, MoneyGram","Supply Ability":"50000pcs per month","Packaging Details":"PP bag + Carton +pallet","material":"Steel, iron, or stainless steel","surface":"Chrome plated or as your requirement","size":"widely and can be customization","package":"Bulk packaging with carton packs or upon customers' request","production time":"15-25 days","usage":"Use on dog collars","moq":"1500 pcs and up","goods of origin":"China"}}